Vol. I · No. 35 Price: One Tinfoil Hat

“All the News That’s Unfit to Believe”

WIRE COPY

John J. McGraw Monument in Truxton, New York

John J. McGraw Monument in Truxton, New York
Image: Atlas Obscura

There are in Truxton, New York, three interrelated sites associated with legendary baseball manager John J. McGraw, who was born in that Central New York town in 1873. The three are a monument to the native son, a baseball field named in his honor, and a sign memorializing the game played at John J. McGraw Field that funded the carving and installation of the memorial to McGraw.

McGraw’s father, also named John, emigrated to the United States in 1856. In his first fifteen years in America, John Sr. served in the Union Army during the Civil War, married and fathered a daughter, suffered the death of his wife, and relocated to Truxton. There, he married Ellen Comerfort, who bore seven children of which the younger John McGraw was the eldest.

Young McGraw had a difficult childhood. The family of ten was poor in an era before public assistance. When he was 12, a diphtheria epidemic struck the area, killing his mother and four of his siblings, including his older half-sister. John Sr. never recovered from the trauma of burying a second wife and became physically abusive to his namesake. McGraw fils ran away at 12 and a neighbor persuaded the father to let the boy live with her and her two sons. …

More from the Wednesday, November 11, 2026 Edition