Vol. I · No. 42 Price: One Tinfoil Hat

“All the News That’s Unfit to Believe”

WIRE COPY

Supermarket cheddar beats Cathedral City and Pilgrims in taste test

Supermarket cheddar beats Cathedral City and Pilgrims in taste test
Image: The Mirror: Weird News

This budget-friendly cheese has come out on top

Christmas is just over five weeks away, and when the festive season kicks off, so does the season of cheese boards. Of course, no self-respecting cheese board is complete without a gorgeous sharp, crumbly cheddar — but which one offers the best combination of value and taste?

Thankfully, consumer champion Which? rounded up 75 cheese lovers to put 11 extra mature cheddars through their paces. The blind taste test has revealed that a budget supermarket own-brand has beaten Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice to claim the top spot.

The Which? taste test of extra-mature cheddars pitched eight supermarket own-brands against one another, alongside three well-known branded options

What is the best mature cheddar?

More from the Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Edition